Short-Term Rentals (Airbnb) vs. Long-Term Leases: Which is Best in 2025?

Last Updated: 12/14/2025 | Category: Investing Strategy

The rise of platforms like Airbnb and VRBO has revolutionized real estate investing. But with increasing regulations and market saturation, is the "Airbnb Gold Rush" over? We compare the high-effort, high-reward world of short-term rentals against the stability of traditional long-term leasing.

Table of Contents

The Case for Short-Term Rentals (Airbnb/VRBO)

Pros:

  • Higher Income Potential: You can often charge per night what a long-term tenant pays per week. Gross income can be 2-3x higher.
  • Flexibility: You can use the property yourself when it's vacant.
  • Less Wear and Tear? Counter-intuitively, because guests are there less often and cleaners are in constantly, the property is improved more frequently.

Cons:

  • High Vacancy Risk: Income is inconsistent and seasonal.
  • Active Management: Managing guest communications, cleaning, and turnover is a part-time job.
  • Strict Regulations: Many cities are banning or heavily restricting STRs.

The Case for Long-Term Rentals

Pros:

  • Consistent Income: You know exactly how much you'll make every month for a year.
  • Passive Income: Once a tenant is placed, you might only hear from them a few times a year.
  • Utility Costs: Tenants typically pay their own utilities (water, electric, gas).

Cons:

  • Lower Gross Cash Flow: Capped by market rent.
  • Eviction Difficulty: Removing a bad tenant can be a long, expensive legal nightmare.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Factor Short-Term (Airbnb) Long-Term (Traditional)
Income Potential High (Variable) Moderate (Stable)
Management Effort High Low
Furnishing Cost $5k - $15k+ $0 (Usually)

The Verdict

Choose Short-Term if you want to maximize cash flow and are willing to treat it like a hospitality business. Ideally, buy in vacation hotspots.

Choose Long-Term if you want true passive income and wealth building through appreciation and loan paydown.

Calculate Your Profits

Whether you choose STR or LTR, numbers don't lie. Run the analysis now.

Calculate Rental Yield

About the Author

Veroman Youness

Veroman Youness

Real Estate Investor, Market Analyst, and Founder of Prophetequity

Veroman Youness is a real estate investor, market analyst, and founder of Prophetequity, a platform dedicated to helping new and experienced investors make smarter property decisions. With years of hands-on experience in residential investing, rental strategies, and market evaluation, Veroman breaks down complex real-estate concepts into clear, actionable insights.

His work focuses on helping first-time home buyers, guiding investors toward profitable opportunities, and simplifying the ever-changing real estate market. Whether you’re looking to buy your first home, build long-term wealth through property investments, or stay ahead of market trends, Veroman’s practical guidance empowers you to make confident, well-informed decisions.

When he's not analyzing deals or writing guides, Veroman spends his time exploring emerging real-estate technologies and helping new investors build their first portfolio.

Read more about our team